MTG Innistrad: Midnight Hunt cards worth money

A return to the plane of Innistrad in Magic: The Gathering has ushered in several Midnight Hunt cards worth money. 

Released digitally on Sept. 16 and globally on Sept. 24, Innistrad: Midnight Hunt (MID) highlights werewolves and humans fighting back against creatures of the night. The set contained three planeswalkers, along with a number of Mythic Rare and Rare creatures/spells with monetary potential. 

WotC released the Innistrad: Double Feature set at the start of 2022, creating even more alternative versions of MID cards that have skyrocketed in value on the secondary market over time. Most are found within the Innistrad: Crimson Vow set while a handful of MID cards outvalue all the alternative-art Double Feature versions.

Heading into the release of Phyrexia: All Will Be One, most of the regular versions in MID have dropped below $10. But alternative treatments and arts have maintained their value, especially on The Meathook Massacre, a legendary Enchantment that is banned from Standard.

From werewolf synergy to demons and dragons, here are the MID cards worth the most money, according to data from MTGGoldfish, TCGPlayer, and MTGStocks. All prices are subject to change and updates will take place after set releases and major tournaments.

The Meathook Massacre

Despite getting banned in the MTG Standard format, the Double Feature version of The Meathook Massacre is still valued at over $200 when in mint condition. The legendary Enchantment’s other versions have maintained their value as well, as The Meathook Massacre is still playable in Commander and Pioneer.

• Double Feature: $245 to $255
• Prerelease foil: $65
• Extended foil: $85 to $90
• Foil: 52
• Extended non-foil: $60
• Regular: $45 to $50

Wrenn and Seven

The Wrenn and Seven planeswalker card from VOW is mostly played in the Commander format, lacking support against the Standard meta. Despite the amount of graveyard hate in Standard, the legendary planeswalker does show up in a few select brews. Value-wise, Wrenn and Seven have fared well, between their various versions.

• Double Feature: $65 to $70
• Borderless foil: $16 to $18
• Prerelease foil: $11
• Regular: $8 to $10

Arlinn, the Pack’s Hope

Arlinn, the Pack’s Hope was a great Mythic Rare in Limited but failed to pop off in Standard. But she has seen gameplay in the Commander format as an alternate commander in conjunction with Tovolar, Dire Overlord. Despite getting overlooked for a while, Arlinn, the Pack’s Hope has slowly started to rise in value leading up to ONE.

• Double Feature foil: $48 to $55
• Showcase foil : $11
• Prerelease foil: $10
• Regular: $7

Teferi, Who Slows the Sunset

Teferi, Who Slows the Sunset slotted right into multiple Commander builds, and has seen play in Standard and Pioneer formats as well. The planeswalker has risen and dropped in value like a rollercoaster since the release of DMU but has steadied out heading into the launch of ONE.

• Double Feature: $50 to $55
• Borderless foil: $12 to $15
• Prerelease foil: $11
• Regular: $6

Haunted Ridge

Haunted Ridge is the most expensive land within the MID set. Showcasing dual color options in Black and Red, the Rare land is worth between $39 to $45 for its Double Feature foil version. The regular version is valued at around $14.

Lier, Disciple of the Drowned

Lier, Disciple of the Drowned is a unique Mythic Rare five-drop that provides each Instant and Sorcery card in your graveyard Flashback. The legendary human wizard was valued between $7 and $8 following the global release of MID. The launch of VOW saw the human wizard rise in price to around $9. And heading into the launch of ONE, Lier, Disciple of the Drowned is still priced at around $9.

The Double Feature version of Lier, Disciple of the Drowned is worth around $35 to $40.

Card prices within the MID set are subject to change. We’ll update prices and entries following the global launch of new MTG Standard-legal sets and major Magic tournaments.

Images via WotC, Magic: The Gathering.

Update July 27, 1.45pm CT: All prices and MID cards worth money were updated heading into the 2022 Standard rotation.

Update Oct. 24, 5.30pm CT: All cards within the MID set had their prices updated heading into the 2022 Magic World Championship and the release of The Brothers’ War.

Update Jan. 29, 4.30pm CT: All cards within the MID set and Double Feature were updated heading into the launch of Phryrexia: All Will Be One.

This article includes affiliate links, which may provide small compensation to Dot Esports.