All MTG cards worth money in Phyrexia: All Will Be One

The Multiverse war in Magic: The Gathering began with the release of Phyrexia: All Will Be One, a standard-legal set showcasing a variety of card-style treatments and powerful cards for all formats. 

Having globally launched on Feb. 10, the Phyrexia: All Will Be One set contained a total of 271 regular cards. Also included in the set are a wide variety of card-style variants known as booster fun treatments. New card-style treatments within the ONE set included borderless manga art, Step and Compleat foils, and Oil Slick foils that were only found within the Compleat bundle. 

The ONE set also included a cycle of Concept Praetor art, with Sheoldred, the Apocalypse foil Concept Praetor version priced around $95 to $110.

Prices following the release of ONE were above average with some card variants remaining valued around $100. Following the launch of March of the Machine (MOM), prices did drop slightly while variants with an oil-slick foil treatment remained somewhat of a mystery.

All ONE card prices

All prices are subject to change. Values shown at the time of writing are average prices from sites like MTGGoldfish, TCGPlayer, and MTGStocks. Prices will be updated after major Standard tournaments, Standard-legal releases, and monthly thereafter.

Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines

Elesh Norn is the face of Phyrexia: All Will Be One. Of all the cards within the set, Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines has the most variants. The Phyrexian Praetor has had an impact on the Commander format and has seen small amounts of gameplay in MTG formats like Standard, Modern, and Pioneer. 

• Oil Slick foil: $85 to $100
• Step and Compleat Phyrexian: $80 to $100
• Phyrexian Judge foil: $170 to $185
• Borderless manga foil: $105 to $120
• Phyrexian foil: $80 to $100
• Concept Praetor foil: $65 to $75
• Concept Praetor Step and Compleat: $70 to $80
• Showcase Step and Compleat: $80 to $95
• Prerelease promo: $55 to $60
• Borderless manga: $42 to $50
• Foil: $40 to $43
• Regular: $30 to $35

Atraxa, Grand Unifier

Atraxa, Grand Unifier is a four-color seven-drop legendary creature in ONE with a host of keywords and 7/7 stats. The Phyrexian angel slotted right into the Commander format and has even seen play through a variety of competitive reanimation builds within Constructed Standard. The increased play in Standard boosted the value of Atraxa, Grand Unifier by over 200 percent in one week, and then decreased slightly. But Atraxa, Grand Unifier didn’t drop to the price she was before the spike.

• Oil Slick foil: $70 to 90
• Showcase Step and Compleat: $50 to $70
• Showcase foil: $35 to $42
• Foil: $25 to $27
• Prerelease foil: $42 to $48
• Regular: $22 to $25

Mondrak, Glory Dominus

There are a total of five Dominus within the ONE set, with Mondrak, Glory Dominus having maintained the most value since the set was released. The Phyrexian horror slots into a variety of Commander decks, producing twice the amount of tokens every time one is created. Mondrak has even seen Standard gameplay in go-wide token decks.

• Borderless Step and Compleat: $40 to $48
• Oil Slick foil: $50 to $60
• Prerelease foil: $40
• Foil: $28 to $32
• Showcase: $28
• Regular: $27 to $28

Sword of Forge and Frontier

Filling in the ninth slot in the Mirrodin Sword cycle is Sword of Forge and Frontier. The Artifact Equipment has protection against the MTG colors Red and Green while providing card advantage when an equipped creature deals combat damage to an opponent. The Sword of Forge and Frontier has constantly seen play in the Commander format, along with Pioneer decks like Gruul Midrange and Mono-White Humans.

• Oil Slick foil: $39 to $48
• Prerelease foil: $32 to $35
• Foil: $20
• Regular: $18 to $19

Vraska, Betrayal’s Sting

Vraska was Compleated in the ONE set, showcased through her planeswalker card, Vraska, Betrayal’s Sting. Her Compleated planeswalker card found a home in Commander Infect decks and several Standard Constructed decks. Vraska, Betrayal’s Sting had a price spike in February, but dipped slightly heading into the release of March of the Machine.

• Borderless Step and Compleat: $30 to $50
• Borderless manga foil: $30 to $35
• Oil Slick foil: $20 to $25
• Prerelease foil: $19 to $21
• Phyrexian foil: $14 to $15
• Foil: $14
• Regular: $8 to $9

All Will Be One

All Will Be One is a five-drop Mono-Red Enchantment that has slotted into a number of Commander decks. The Mythic Rare saw a price spike in February, but has since dropped back down, although not to the price it was prior to the spike.

• Oil Slick foil: $20 to $25
• Prerelease foil: $17 to $20
• Foil: $10
• Regular: $8 to $9

Phyrexian Obliterator

Reprinted in ONE, Phyrexian Obliterator has a history of variations worth money on the secondary market. The Phyrexian horror has an Oil Slick version, along with a Step and Compleat foil treatment. Phyrexian Obliterator is mostly played in the Commander format and some Standard decks like Mono-Black and Golgari Midrange.  

• Step and Compleat foil: $20
• Oil Slick foil: $25 to $35
• Prerelease foil: $14
• Showcase foil: $9 to $11
• Foil: $8 to $10
• Regular: $7 to $9

Jace, the Perfected Mind 

Featuring a low casting cost, Jace, the Perfected Mind is played within MTG formats like Modern, Standard, Pioneer, and Commander. Since the release of ONE, the planeswalker has steadily maintained its value on the secondary market.

• Borderless Step and Compleat: $15 to $20
• Oil slick foil: $15 to $18
• Prerelease foil: $11
• Regular: $5 to $6

Tyrranax Rex

Played mostly in the Commander format, the seven-drop Dinosaur has also been showing up in the Modern and Standard formats following the release of March of the Machine. The Phyrexian Dinosaur can’t get countered and is difficult to remove once on the battlefield with a Ward of four.

• OIl slick foil: $17 to $20
• Prerelease foil: $12 to $15
• Foil: $6 to $7
• Regular: $5 to $6

All images via WotC.

Update Feb. 6 2:40pm CT: All ONE card prices were updated for the digital launch.

Update Feb. 9 8pm CT: All ONE card prices were updated following the global launch.

Update Feb. 14 2:45pm CT: All ONE card prices were updated heading into the first Pro Tour tournament of 2023.

Update Feb. 17 10am CT: All ONE card prices were updated for the start of Pro Tour Phyrexia.

Update March 24 8:30pm CT: All ONE card prices were updated leading up to the release of MOM spoilers.

Update April 27 1:30pm CT: All ONE card prices were updated following the release of MOM.