Denial Esports owner Robby Ringnalda allegedly owes players more than $35,000

Allegations against the CEO have been ongoing for years.

Image via Denial Esports

Esports law firms Morrison/Lee and ESG Law are standing together to hold Denial Esports CEO Robby Ringnalda accountable for player exploitation.

“Morrison/Lee and ESG Law are normally on opposite sides of the table—today we stand shoulder to shoulder,” the lawyers said in a joint statement on Twitter. “Player mistreatment is an unacceptable part of this industry, and we are committed to eradicating such behavior wherever possible.”

Related: Former EnVision owner reportedly owes team thousands of dollars

Morrison/Lee and ESG Law are representing players and staff owed more than $35,000 from Ringnalda, who allegedly violated contracts relating to “unpaid salary, unpaid housing expenses, and un-reimbursed tournament-entry fees.” Ringnalda and Denial “consistently failed to honor its obligations while the players were on the team, and players were forced to pay for rent and other expenses out of their own pockets, put utility bills in their own names, and get loans from friends and family members to cover expenses they couldn’t afford without support,” according to Morrison/Lee and ESG Law.

Problems with Denial have been ongoing for years. In Sept. 2015, Denial owed its Halo team $3,000. In 2017, it owned a Smash Melee pro missing salary payments, according to an ESPN report. Players from Denial’s H1Z1, Counter-Strike: Global Offensive, Overwatch, and Paladins teams are also reportedly owed money.

“Ringnalda has now shut down Denial Esports and seems to have moved on from the esports industry,” the law firms wrote. “We’re quite sure from his responses to us thus far, or lack thereof, that he is confident that his misconduct will be forgotten and not affect his future business interests.”

In July 2017, Ringnalda and Black Dog Venture Partners CEO Scott Kelly partnered to open Black Dog Gaming, an esports consultancy firm. When reached for comment, Black Dog Gaming CEO Scott Kelly said Ringnalda “is not associated with Black Dog Gaming in any capacity.” Kelly declined further comment.

Update, 9:50am CT: Added additional information from Black Dog Gaming CEO Scott Kelly.

About the author
Nicole Carpenter

Nicole Carpenter is a reporter for Dot Esports. She lives in Massachusetts with her cat, Puppy, and dog, Major. She's a Zenyatta main who'd rather be playing D.Va.