Fortnite might be on top of Twitch, but it doesn’t pack the same punch - Dot Esports

Fortnite might be on top of Twitch, but it doesn’t pack the same punch

Warzone has been a mainstay on Twitch since March.

Screengrab via Epic Games

There was a time when Fortnite was the game to beat on Twitch. Numerous developers made new battle royale titles to compete with Epic Games’ cartoonish shooter.

But every time one of those games burst onto the scene, their fall was like clockwork. 

In 2018 and 2019, a few games of note were introduced into the battle royale marketplace, each with their own advantages. Call of Duty’s initial attempt at the battle royale genre in the fall of 2018 had the fortune of being tied to one of the most established, successful shooter franchises in the history of gaming. Apex Legends later came along as EA’s take on the battle royale genre in 2019 and its early viewership on Twitch smashed numerous records. 

For a few weeks, both games showed the potential to be the top title on Twitch. They seemingly had Fortnite on the ropes and were poised to be the most-watched game in Twitch’s most popular genre.

But Fortnite has consistently been able to put those games to sleep for more than two years just by releasing new content.

Epic’s ability to take a game that everyone knows and completely reshape its map, items, cosmetics, and playstyles from season to season has allowed Fortnite to be one of Twitch’s most-watched games since its rise in early 2018.

Similar to how players break down buildings and use materials to rebuild the world around them from game to game, Epic isn’t afraid to make drastic changes to its game’s map or mechanics.

But following the release of Chapter Two, season four on Aug. 27, are Epic’s strategies still working? Or is the game treading water as it fights Call of Duty’s latest attempt at the battle royale genre in the form of Warzone?

Chapter Two, season four

Fortnite’s latest season is filled with everything a comic book geek might want. Marvel superhero cosmetics are abundant and there are even “Mystic Weapons” that allow players to feel like a Marvel superhero in-game.

Centered around the “Nexus War,” this season’s theme is distinctly unique. While we’ve seen hero-related aspects in Fortnite before in the form of partnerships with the Avengers movies, Epic is taking the hero connection to a new level.

Peaking at around 459,000 viewers on the first day of the season, Fortnite has generated more than 42 million hours watched in the past two weeks, according to Twitch stat tracker SullyGnome. Those figures put the game behind only Just Chatting and League of Legends, which has had LEC and LCS Summer Splits being decided.

While those statistics seem impressive in a vacuum, they don’t match the audience that the game has been able to reach in the past.

Image via SullyGnome

In the past year, Fortnite’s viewership has beaten that mark more than a handful of times, including “The Device” event in June and the “Black Hole” event last October that eclipsed 2.3 million and 1.6 million viewers respectively on Twitch.

Both of those grandiose events were followed by sizable viewership on Twitch to start the season, but other Chapter Two seasons (two and four) haven’t had as much success despite having all of the same types of changes that brought down games like Apex

To some degree, Epic’s in-game events drive excitement and early viewership for Fortnite’s new seasons. But another element complicating Fortnite’s situation is the presence of competition that the game hasn’t been able to push out.

Battle of the royales

Activision may not have hit a home run with its first attempt at making Call of Duty a battle royale game, but since its March 10 release, the free-to-play Warzone battle royale for CoD has been a mainstay on Twitch.

With 535 million hours watched in the past 180 days on Twitch, CoD isn’t ahead of Fortnite, but it’s doing well enough that Epic’s title doesn’t have a monopoly anymore. Fortnite is the fourth most-watched content on Twitch in that time with 597 million hours watched.

Image via SullyGnome

While Fortnite has more viewers, CoD has edged out the cartoonish battle royale game at the top end of Twitch. Four of the top 10 most-watched channels on Twitch in the past six months have at least 275 hours of airtime playing CoD.

There’s only one person who has more than 100 hours of airtime playing Fortnite and that’s Tfue, who also has a massive amount of Warzone playtime.

Meanwhile, Epic’s content releases haven’t packed the same punch against its competition. Since Warzone’s release, Epic has launched two seasons of Fortnite and had numerous in-game events, but Warzone’s viewership is still right behind the more playfully-toned battle royale game.

Fortnite isn’t on a decline, but it doesn’t have the same level of control over the genre that it once did.

With the loss of many top content creators, Fortnite doesn’t possess the monopolistic level of power that it once did over the influencer-driven battle royale space—and its inability to suppress Warzone over the past six months is proof.